Everyone is familiar with the Five Second Rule. You
drop your M&M, “Five Second Rule!” The M&M is totally fine. It wasn’t
on the ground long enough to be contaminated with anything because germs need
time to transfer. Or do they? Researchers at the University of New Jersey
recently performed a number of test to see if this was true.
The food that they used was watermelon, bread, bread with butter and gummy candy. They
tested these food types on stainless steel, tile, wood and carpet. They found that
the food with the highest transfer rate was watermelon regardless of contact
time, disproving the Five Second Rule. The food with the least amount of
bacterial transfer was the gummy candy. The watermelon probably had the highest
rate because it’s mostly water and water helps with the transfer of bacteria. The
tile transferred more bacteria to buttered bread than any other surface.
Stainless steel transferred the most to the gummy candy.
In
a way, the Five Second Rule is almost true. The longer a piece of food stays in
contact with the inoculated surface, the more bacteria it will have. The transfer rate depends on food type, surface type, and the amount
of contact time. So the next time you drop your M&M, think about what you
might be putting in your mouth before eating the thing.
Further
Reading:
http://aem.asm.org/content/early/2016/08/15/AEM.01838-16
This topic is quite interesting due to the prevalence of people who use the “5 second rule”. I wonder if more people read articles of studies like this one, if they would just throw the food away instead of throwing it into their mouths.
ReplyDeleteIf I remember correctly, there were similar studies performed in people dropping food and contamination rate of E.coli in those food. I do not remember the specific food, but I remember that there was a 90% contamination of E.coli in these foods. Honestly, I remember reading that research and being scared, so I try my best to not drop any food.
ReplyDeleteIf I remember correctly, there were similar studies performed in people dropping food and contamination rate of E.coli in those food. I do not remember the specific food, but I remember that there was a 90% contamination of E.coli in these foods. Honestly, I remember reading that research and being scared, so I try my best to not drop any food.
ReplyDeleteKymeri-
ReplyDeleteThis is a very interesting, relatable, and slightly disturbing topic (unfortunately, I am guilty of using the “5 second rule”). What I found to be the most interesting part of this study was all of the different variables tested. I would have never thought about things like type of food or floor surface altering the likelihood of bacteria transfer. After reading your post and explanation about watermelon, I now understand how type of food can increase bacteria transfer. But, I am still not sure how the type of floor surface would make a difference. With that being said, I think if a person were to drop food outdoors they would be less likely to use the “5 second rule”. An interesting future study would be to compare bacteria transfer from indoor and outdoor surfaces to see which actually contains more bacteria.
That would be interesting. Part of me always considered outdoors to be cleaner. At least it gets rained on, right?
DeleteI think most of us, myself included, use the five second rule to justify eating food off the floor, knowing deep down that something likely got on it. Whatever it takes to help us sleep at night with a guilt free conscience. But this is very eye opening to see the results of a study testing this very act. While I am more prone to using the five second rule on a floor I know has recently been cleaned (not that this is a frequent occurrence), this study will definitely make me reconsider my actions. I think I'll stick with Javier and just try not to drop the food in the first place so I won't be tempted.
ReplyDeleteI'm definitely guilty of the "5 second rule" and probably still will be after reading this article since I haven't gotten noticeably sick yet. I did find it to be a very interesting article though! It makes sense why the watermelon has the highest transfer rate. I would think the bread with butter would just end up being nasty once it came off of the floor. I do know my limits with the 5 second rule and I definitely would not be eating anything with butter or watermelon off of the ground! I think it was really interesting that the different surfaces altered the bacteria growing on it. I wonder if the floors were treated the same was before each trial or if they just dropped food on the different surfaces. That could have an impact.
ReplyDeleteI believe everything was treated the same way. I did find it interesting that the stainless steel had a high transfer rate. I would have thought it was carpet. But I guess it makes sense because it's a flat surface.
DeleteI am a chronic 5 second rule user that believes that there is nothing wrong with food dropping on the floor unless it is visibly dirty. Reading this study has made me have a realization of there actually being a fault in this rule, but I feel like I won't change my ways. Your explanation for why the watermelon may have a higher transfer rate is great and another reason for this could be that watermelon is porous/spongy in texture. I am curious about why the gummy bears had less of a transfer rate though.
ReplyDeleteMy guess would be because it has the least amount of moisture, at least on the outside.
DeleteThe good news is my gummy candy has less bacterial transfer than other foods. I knew there was a benefit to junk food! If I were to have guessed, I may have put plain bread in last place so it is interesting that the gummy substance out lasted.
ReplyDeleteDoes the five second rule apply to your hands? Well washing should help a lot right?
ReplyDeleteHints: Nope.
So all that money I spend at Bath and Body Works is basically a waste?
DeleteAt least me hands smell nice.